Super Bowl Organic Buffalo Wings
Marinated, grilled buffalo-style wings with a vinegar, chili and Worcestershire marinade, served with a cool blue cheese dipping sauce for game day.
Ingredients
Wings
Organic marinade
Organic blue cheese dipping sauce
Steps
- Marinate the wingsCombine the marinade ingredients and mix well. Place the chicken wings in a large resealable bag and pour the marinade over the top. Turn to coat and refrigerate for 2 to 6 hours.
- Make the blue cheese sauceCombine the blue cheese, sour cream, mayonnaise, garlic and Worcestershire sauce in a bowl. Stir until smooth. Add enough milk to give the sauce the consistency of pancake batter. Season with salt and pepper. Cover and refrigerate for at least 1 hour.
- Preheat the grillPreheat the grill and set it up for a low fire.
- Grill the wingsRemove the wings from the marinade and reserve the marinade. Place the wings on the hot grill over a low fire. Grill until done (about 20 minutes), brushing with the reserved marinade halfway through the cooking time. Boil the used marinade for a minute or two first, or use a portion set aside before the wings went in.
- ServeServe the wings with the blue cheese sauce and celery sticks.
These are marinated, grilled buffalo-style wings with a cool blue cheese dipping sauce, built for game day. The marinade is vinegar-based with chili powder, red pepper flakes and Worcestershire, so the heat comes from the wing itself instead of a sauce poured on after. The recipe makes about 24 wings. Make more than you think you need, because wings go fast.
The full ingredient list and steps are in the recipe card. A few things that help the wings come out right:
Tips for better wings
- Plan the marinating time. Wings need 2 to 6 hours in the fridge. Don't go much past 6, because the cider vinegar starts to make the meat texture mushy. The blue cheese sauce needs at least 1 hour in the fridge, so make both the same morning. For more on why marinade matters, see Better Marinade = Better For You.
- Keep the fire low. Wings have skin and fat that drip. On a gas grill, set the burners to low and watch for flare-ups. If one side runs hotter, move the wings around. Our guide on how hot a gas grill should get explains what low, medium and high usually mean.
- Check doneness with a thermometer. About 20 minutes is a good guide, but wing size and grill temperature change that. Chicken is safe at 165°F in the thickest part. Wings are often better a little past that, so give them a few extra minutes if the skin still looks soft.
- Handle the reserved marinade safely. The marinade in the bag has touched raw chicken. Either pour a small portion into a separate bowl before the wings go in, or boil the used marinade for a minute or two before you brush it on. Don't brush it on in the last few minutes with no further cooking.
- Start with clean grates. Wings stick to old residue. If your grates need work first, see how to clean BBQ grates. Oil the grates lightly after preheating.
- Thin the sauce slowly. Add the milk a little at a time. You want it about as thick as pancake batter, so it still clings to a wing or a celery stick.
If your grill has trouble holding a steady low temperature, or you want it cleaned and checked before game day, a pro can look at the burners and grates. Find an insured grill pro near you.
FAQ
How long should I marinate the buffalo wings?
Marinate them in the refrigerator for 2 to 6 hours. Because the marinade has a full cup of cider vinegar, don't leave the wings much longer than 6 hours or the texture can turn soft.
How long do the wings take on the grill?
About 20 minutes over a low fire, brushing with the reserved marinade halfway through. Check that the thickest part reads at least 165°F, and cook a few minutes longer if the skin is still soft.
Is it safe to brush the leftover marinade on the wings?
Only if you handle it right. The marinade that sat with raw chicken should be boiled for a minute or two first, or you can set aside a separate portion before the wings go into the bag.
Can I make the blue cheese sauce ahead of time?
Yes. It needs at least 1 hour covered in the refrigerator, so making it the morning of the game works well. Stir it and add a splash of milk if it thickens.
What should I serve with the wings?
The recipe is served with the blue cheese sauce and celery sticks.
More recipes
See all →
Two-Zone Bison Burgers with Ancho Rub and Garlic-Chive Sauce
Bison is lean and dries out fast, so these patties get a little cold butter, a hard sear, and a finish on the cool side of the grill. The ancho-cumin…

Grilled Chicken with Peach BBQ Sauce Recipe
A juicy grilled chicken recipe with a homemade peach BBQ sauce made from fresh peaches, garlic, mustard and smoked paprika, plus tips for getting it …

Grilled Loaded Nachos
Seasoned beef, black beans, jalapeños and melted cheese on crispy chips, all cooked on the grill. Easy to make for game day or any backyard get-toget…
